Freezer Jam

Do you have to refrigerate a strawberry rhubarb pie after it's baked?

A baked strawberry rhubarb pie can sit covered at room temperature for a short time. Refrigerate it for longer storage, and reheat slices to crisp the crust.

On this page
  1. Room temperature
  2. Refrigerating
  3. Reheating to crisp the crust
  4. When to refrigerate sooner
  5. A note on jam

A baked strawberry rhubarb pie can sit covered at room temperature for a short time. Many cooks keep a fruit pie out for a day or two, but if you’re not sure how long it has been out, refrigerate it or throw it out. For longer storage, put it in the refrigerator. Refrigeration keeps the pie for longer, but it can soften the crust, so reheat slices before serving.

Room temperature

  • Cool the pie first. Let it cool on a rack. Putting a hot pie straight into a covered dish traps steam and makes the crust soggy.
  • Cover it loosely. Lay foil or plastic wrap over the pie without pressing on the top. This keeps dust and pests off without sealing in steam.
  • Watch the time. General food safety guidance says perishable food shouldn’t sit out for more than about two hours. Fruit pies are often kept longer, but if you’re unsure, refrigerate the pie sooner.

Refrigerating

Put the pie in the refrigerator when you want it to last longer. Cold, moist conditions can make the bottom crust soggy and the filling looser, especially after a day or two. Cover the pie, or store leftover slices in an airtight container.

Reheating to crisp the crust

Warm a slice in a toaster oven or a regular oven rather than the microwave. A short time in a warm oven helps the crust crisp again. Warm the slice all the way through before serving.

When to refrigerate sooner

  • The pie has been out longer than you’re comfortable with.
  • Slices have been cut and left out.
  • The room is warm.

A note on jam

Pies and jams have different storage rules. Freezer jam isn’t shelf-stable, so it must stay in the refrigerator or freezer. For freezer jam storage times, see how long freezer jam lasts. For a strawberry rhubarb jam, see the strawberry rhubarb freezer jam guide or strawberry rhubarb jam without pectin. For the general freezer jam overview, see the freezer jam guide.

The complete guide to freezer jam

Freezer Jam: How to Make It With Instant, Low-Sugar or No Pectin
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →