Yes, you can make freezer jam with frozen fruit. Thaw it fully, crush it, and measure after crushing. Thawing releases juice, and that juice is part of the flavor. Frozen fruit can give a slightly softer, less chunky texture than fresh, but the method is the same.
Choose unsweetened fruit
Check the label before you buy or use frozen fruit. Unsweetened fruit is the simplest choice, because the sugar in your recipe is the only sugar in the jam. Sweetened frozen fruit, packed in syrup or with added sugar, adds sugar the recipe didn’t plan for. The sources checked for this guide don’t include a tested adjustment for that, so use a recipe written for sweetened fruit rather than changing the sugar in a standard recipe.
Thaw in the refrigerator
- Put the frozen fruit in a covered bowl in the refrigerator.
- Let it thaw fully. Icy pieces in the middle will throw off your measurements.
- Keep the juice. It adds flavor and goes into the jam with the fruit.
Drain only if it’s very wet
If the thawed fruit is very watery, pour off some of the excess liquid before you crush and measure. A little juice is fine. Pouring off too much can take away the fruit’s body, so drain only as much as you need to keep the mixture from running.
Crush and measure after thawing
Crush the thawed fruit the way you would fresh fruit: mash it for a rustic jam, or pulse it briefly for a smoother spread. Then measure the crushed fruit in a dry measuring cup. Measuring whole fruit or fruit before thawing gives the wrong amount, and the sugar balance will be off.
Let it set for 24 hours
Set time comes from your pectin box, which for most Sure-Jell recipes is 24 hours at room temperature. Some online recipes suggest a much shorter rest of about 30 minutes. That conflicts with the box, so follow the box. Check the jam after 24 hours before you decide whether it has set. If it’s still loose, see the troubleshooting guide.
Texture and flavor
Frozen fruit can make a softer, less chunky jam. If you want a smooth spread, mash it well. If you want pieces of fruit, mash lightly. Taste the thawed fruit first. Freezer jam doesn’t cook down, so bland fruit makes bland jam.
Frozen fruit in specific recipes
- Strawberries: the less-sugar Sure-Jell recipe works with thawed strawberries.
- Mango: thaw completely before you mash it.
- Peaches: the peach recipes assume fresh peaches. Thaw and drain as described above, and check the amounts against the recipe.
Storage
Frozen-fruit freezer jam is stored the same way as any other freezer jam. Keep it in the refrigerator for up to about 3 weeks, or freeze it for up to a year. Thaw frozen jars in the refrigerator. For details, read how long freezer jam lasts. For the full process of choosing pectin and sugar, see the freezer jam guide.