Short answer: usually yes
Usually, yes. Plums contain enough natural pectin to set a jam with sugar, lemon juice and a steady boil. You do not need packaged pectin for a soft, spreadable jam. How firm the jam gets depends on the variety, how ripe the fruit is and how long you cook it.
What changes how much pectin plums have
Plums are not all the same. Four things make the biggest difference:
- Variety. Tart cooking plums usually set more readily than very sweet, juicy dessert plums.
- Ripeness. Slightly underripe plums have more pectin than fully ripe, soft ones. Ripe fruit still sets, but it often needs a longer cook.
- Skins. Pectin is concentrated in the skins. Leaving them on helps the set and adds color.
- Acid. Lemon juice adds the acid that the set needs. Plums are fairly mild in acid, so a little lemon helps.
Because plums have a moderate amount of pectin rather than a large amount, the set can vary from batch to batch. The cold plate test is the best guide.
Keep the skins on and add lemon
Two simple habits help plum jam set without added pectin:
- Keep the skins on. Chop the plums with the skins intact. They soften as the jam cooks.
- Add lemon juice. Use 2 tablespoons of bottled lemon juice for about 2 pounds of plums, or follow your recipe.
Mix some slightly firmer plums into the batch if you can. If you only have very ripe plums, expect a softer set and give the jam a little longer on the heat.
When plums will not set on their own
Some batches stay loose even with lemon and the skins on. The usual causes are:
- Too little cooking. Plums can take 15 to 30 minutes or more to thicken. Test before you decide the jam has failed.
- Very ripe fruit. Overripe plums have less pectin, so the set is softer.
- Too much water. Juicy plums release a lot of liquid. Keep simmering to let it evaporate.
If the jam still will not set, keep cooking it. Add a little more lemon juice if it still will not thicken.
Adding pectin, if you want a firmer set
You can add packaged pectin if you want a firm, jelly-like set. Follow the directions on the package, because the sugar amounts and timing are specific to the product. Adding pectin changes the recipe, so do not mix a packaged-pectin ratio with a no-pectin method.
You can also add a little natural pectin from apple scraps. The apple cores and peels method shows how to make a pectin stock that you can add to plum jam.
How to check the set
- Put a few small plates in the freezer before you start.
- When the jam looks thick, take the pot off the heat and spoon a little onto a cold plate.
- Wait about a minute, then push the surface with your finger.
- If it wrinkles and holds its shape, the jam is set. If it runs, return it to a simmer and test again in a few minutes.
At sea level, pectin-free jam sets at about 220°F (104°C), and the target is lower at higher altitude.
For a complete plum recipe, including low-sugar and freezer versions, see homemade plum jam without pectin. For the general method, see how to make jam step by step.