Short answer: yes, if the fruit is high in pectin
Yes. You can make jelly from juice without pectin if the juice comes from fruit that is naturally high in pectin and you cook it to the set point. Tart apples, crabapples, quince, cranberries, currants and grapes such as Concord are good choices. Make the juice yourself by cooking the fruit and straining it. Bought juice usually will not set on its own.
Why store-bought juice often will not set
Commercial juice is processed in ways that remove much of its pectin. The USDA’s National Center for Home Food Preservation advises against using commercially canned or frozen fruit juices for pectin-free jelly, because their pectin content is too low. Juice you extract from fresh fruit keeps more of it.
Choose fruit and prepare it
Use firm fruit that is naturally high in pectin. The USDA recommends a mix of about three-quarters ripe fruit and one-quarter underripe fruit. The underripe fruit adds pectin, and the ripe fruit adds flavor.
- Wash the fruit thoroughly.
- Crush soft fruit and berries. Cut firm fruit, such as apples or quince, into small pieces.
- Keep the peels and cores of apples and quince. They add pectin to the juice as it cooks. Discard any stems and leaves.
- Add water only if the fruit is dry. Fruits that need water are listed in tested recipes for each fruit.
Extract the juice
- Put the prepared fruit and any water in a large pot. Bring to a boil, then simmer, stirring to prevent scorching, until the fruit is completely soft.
- Pour the fruit into a colander or strainer set over a bowl, then pour the drained pulp into a jelly bag or a double layer of cheesecloth.
- Let the juice drip through. Do not press or squeeze the bag, because that pushes pulp through and makes cloudy jelly. Leave it to drip for several hours or overnight in a cool place.
As a rough guide, 1 pound of fruit should yield at least 1 cup of clear juice. Measure the juice before you start the jelly.
Cook the jelly
- Measure no more than 6 to 8 cups of juice at a time, so the boil stays manageable.
- Put the juice in a wide, heavy pot with sugar and lemon juice. As a worked example, one home recipe uses 3 cups of juice, 2 cups of sugar and 1 tablespoon of bottled lemon juice. Adjust the sugar to the juice and to taste, and check the proportions against a tested recipe for your fruit.
- Heat over medium heat, stirring until the sugar has dissolved.
- Bring to a full boil, then boil hard, stirring and skimming off foam, until the jelly reaches the set point. This often takes 20 to 25 minutes.
Test for set
The USDA gives two reliable tests.
Sheet test. Dip a cool metal spoon into the boiling jelly. Lift it about 12 inches (30 cm) above the pan, out of the steam, and turn it so the liquid runs off the side. The jelly is done when the drops merge and sheet off the edge of the spoon, rather than dripping as separate drops.
Thermometer. At sea level, jelly sets at about 220°F (104°C). The target is lower at higher altitude, so use the sheet test as well.
Remove the pot from the heat and skim off any foam quickly before you fill the jars.
If the jelly will not set
- Cook it longer. Juice from some fruits needs a longer, harder boil. Test every few minutes.
- Add acid. A little more bottled lemon juice can help the set.
- Add pectin from apple scraps. Simmer apple peels and cores in water, strain the stock and add a small amount to the juice. The apple cores and peels method explains how.
- Start over with better fruit. If the juice is low in pectin, add a tart, high-pectin fruit next time.
Storing jelly
- Refrigerator: Cool the jelly, put it in clean covered jars and refrigerate. Use within a few weeks.
- Freezer: Freeze in freezer-safe containers, leaving about 1/2 inch (1 cm) of room at the top. Use within about six months.
- Shelf-stable jars: Use a tested recipe for the specific fruit. The National Center for Home Food Preservation publishes tested jelly recipes, and the processing times depend on your altitude. Do not process a no-pectin batch in a water bath unless it is from a tested recipe.
For chokecherry jelly from juice, see do I need pectin for chokecherry jelly. For foraged berries, see wild berry jam without pectin. For the general method, see how to make jam step by step. For more jelly recipes, see how to make jelly without pectin.