The short answer
Pepper jelly is a water bath product. Tested pepper jelly recipes are processed in a boiling water canner, not a pressure canner. The vinegar, sugar, and pectin in the recipe are what make that method suitable. Use a tested recipe, and follow its processing time for your jar size and altitude.
Plain peppers are a different case. Peppers packed in water and not pickled are low-acid, and tested guides call for pressure canning them.
Why pepper jelly is a water bath product
Pepper jelly is a sweet, acidic gel. Sugar and pectin create the set, and vinegar adds the acid. Jams and jellies are processed in boiling water, while pressure canners are used for low-acid foods such as plain vegetables and meat. A tested pepper jelly recipe lists water bath processing for this reason.
Plain peppers are a different case
If you are canning peppers without vinegar or sugar, such as chopped bell peppers or jalapeños packed in water, you are working with a low-acid food. Tested guides call for pressure canning those, not a boiling water bath. Pickled peppers, made with a tested vinegar brine, are a water bath product.
The rule of thumb is this. If the recipe is a jelly or a pickle with vinegar and sugar, follow a tested water bath recipe. If it is plain peppers, follow a tested pressure canning recipe, or freeze or refrigerate them.
Check the recipe before you process
Recipes differ in their vinegar, pepper, and sugar amounts, and those amounts affect acidity. If you change the vinegar or the ratio of pepper to liquid, you may change the balance the recipe was tested for.
Some posted recipes list the ingredients and jar sizes but leave out processing instructions. A recipe with no processing time is not a shelf-stable recipe. Treat it as a refrigerator product, or find a tested recipe that gives a time.
How to water bath pepper jelly
- Prepare the jars. Wash them in hot, soapy water, check for chips, and keep them hot. How to sterilize jars for jam and jelly explains when empty jars must be boiled first.
- Cook the jelly to a full rolling boil, and test for the set point as your recipe directs. Skim the foam.
- Fill the jars hot, leaving 1/4 inch of headspace. Wipe the rims, add new lids, and screw on the bands until fingertip tight.
- Process in a boiling water canner for the time in your recipe, adjusted for altitude. How long to water bath can jam explains the timing.
- Cool the jars undisturbed for 12 to 24 hours, then check the seals. Store sealed jars in a cool, dark place.
Storing pepper jelly
- Processed and sealed: store in a cool, dark place, and follow the guidance in how long homemade jam and jelly lasts.
- Not processed: keep it in the refrigerator, and treat it as a short-term product.
- Once opened: keep it refrigerated.
Safety notes
The acidity and the processing are what keep a shelf-stable pepper jelly safe. Read how to avoid botulism in jam before you change a recipe. If a jar looks or smells wrong when you open it, throw it out. For plain peppers, use a tested pressure canning guide. Pressure cookers are not canners, as pressure cooker jelly explains.