Can you make cherry jelly with sweet or sour cherries?
Yes. Sour (tart) cherries are high in natural pectin and acid, so they set more readily. Sweet cherries are lower in acid and usually need added lemon juice. Most cherry jelly recipes add powdered or liquid pectin to get a reliable set, whichever type of cherry you use.
Sweet vs. sour cherries
- Sour cherries are tart and high in natural pectin. Many recipes leave out the lemon juice.
- Sweet cherries are lower in acid. A recipe for sweet cherries usually adds about 2 tablespoons of lemon juice for balance and set.
Whichever you use, taste the strained juice before you add the sugar. It should taste tart and bright enough to balance the sweetness of the finished jelly.
Ingredients
- Cherries, pitted. Home recipes usually use about 3½ to 4 pounds of whole cherries to make about 3½ cups of strained juice. Yield depends on the cherries, so measure the juice.
- Water, about ½ to 1 cup, for simmering.
- Lemon juice, about 2 tablespoons for sweet cherries, or omitted for sour cherries.
- Powdered or liquid pectin. Follow the package for the amount and the sugar.
- Sugar. Use the amount printed on the pectin package for the juice volume you measure. Regular pectin needs a lot of sugar to set.
- Optional: about ½ teaspoon of butter to reduce foaming, and a splash of almond extract stirred in after cooking.
Step by step
- Wash, stem, and pit the cherries. Save the juice that runs out while you pit them.
- Simmer. Put the cherries and water in a large pot. Simmer for about 10 minutes until the cherries are soft.
- Strain. Pour the mixture through damp cheesecloth or a jelly bag set over a bowl. Let it drip without squeezing, so the jelly stays clear. Measure the juice.
- Add pectin. Return the juice to the pot. Stir in the lemon juice (if using), the pectin, and the butter (if using). Bring to a full rolling boil over high heat, stirring constantly.
- Add sugar and boil. Stir in the sugar all at once. Return to a full rolling boil, then boil hard for exactly one minute, stirring the whole time.
- Finish. Remove from the heat and skim off the foam. Stir in the almond extract if you are using it.
- Jar. Ladle the hot jelly into hot jars, leaving 1/4-inch headspace. Wipe the rims, add lids, and tighten the bands finger-tight.
- Process or refrigerate. For pantry storage, process in a boiling water canner for a tested time for your jar size and altitude. The National Center for Home Food Preservation (NCHFP) gives times that increase with altitude, so look up yours before you start. For refrigerator storage, skip processing.
- Cool and check. Let the jars rest undisturbed for 12 to 24 hours, then check the seals.
Storage
- Pantry: Sealed jars stored in a cool, dark place can keep for up to about a year.
- Refrigerator: Once a jar is opened, refrigerate it and use it within a few weeks. Sources vary, so check your recipe.
Troubleshooting
- Runny jelly: Give it a day to set. If it is still loose, see how to thicken up jelly without pectin.
- Cloudy jelly: Usually from squeezing the bag or letting pulp through. See why jelly turns cloudy.
- Pits in the jelly: Pit the cherries carefully before cooking, and strain well.
FAQs
Can you use frozen cherries? Yes. Frozen pitted cherries work well. Thaw them, drain off any excess liquid, then simmer and strain as above.
Can you make cherry jelly without pectin? It is possible to cook the juice down to the gel point without added pectin, which is the method in how to make jelly without pectin. Sour cherries are the better candidates. Sweet cherries set less reliably, so a pectin recipe is the safer choice for them.
Why is my cherry jelly cloudy? Squeezing the strainer is the most common cause. The cloudy jelly guide covers the other causes and how to prevent them.
For a similar set-and-strain method with a different fruit, see blueberry jelly. For a spread that keeps the fruit, see low-sugar cherry jam or cherry freezer jam.