Is it better to make blackberry jam with or without pectin?
Neither is better for every cook. Blackberries have enough natural pectin for many recipes to set without help, so a pectin-free jam is a good choice when you want the fruit flavour and a short ingredient list. Commercial pectin is the better choice when you want a firmer, more predictable set in less time. Pick based on how you plan to store the jam and how firm you want it.
Without pectin
Advantages
- The flavour is closer to the fresh berries, which many cooks prefer.
- The ingredient list is short.
- It works well for small refrigerator batches.
Drawbacks
- It takes longer to cook, and you need to test the set.
- The set is softer and less predictable, so a batch sometimes needs a second cook.
- Shelf storage needs a tested canning method, not just a sealed lid.
With pectin
Advantages
- The set is firmer and more consistent.
- It cooks faster.
- The package gives clear amounts for the fruit and sugar.
Drawbacks
- Some cooks feel that added pectin dulls the fresh fruit taste.
- Regular pectin needs the package’s sugar amount, so you cannot cut the sugar much.
- It is one more product to buy and store.
Which should you choose?
- Refrigerator jam, small batch, fruit flavour first: Choose no pectin.
- Shelf-stable jam with a consistent set: Choose a tested pectin recipe, and follow its processing time for your jar size and altitude.
- Lower-sugar jam: Use a pectin made for low- or no-sugar recipes, and follow its package directions. Do not simply cut the sugar in a regular recipe.
Tips for blackberries either way
- Mix ripe and slightly firm berries. A little firm fruit adds natural pectin, which helps a pectin-free jam set.
- Remove seeds if you want a smoother jam. Cook the berries until soft, then press them through a sieve or food mill. Measure the pulp before you add sugar.
- Test the set. Use a cold plate. Spoon a little jam onto a chilled plate, wait about 30 seconds, and push it with a fingertip. A wrinkle means it is set.
- Keep the cook steady. Long cooking can dull the colour and flavour, so do not keep boiling once the jam reaches the set.
For a full pectin-free method, see berry jelly without pectin. If your jam runs thin, see how to thicken up jelly without pectin. For the basics of jelly without pectin, see how to make jelly without pectin.