Jelly Making

What is Martha Stewart's recipe for pepper jelly?

What is Martha Stewart's recipe for pepper jelly? We could not verify her exact steps, so this guide explains a standard method to compare against hers.

On this page
  1. What is Martha Stewart’s recipe for pepper jelly?
  2. What a standard pepper jelly includes
  3. Two common approaches
  4. What to check when you compare recipes

What is Martha Stewart’s recipe for pepper jelly?

We could not verify the exact ingredients or steps in Martha Stewart’s pepper jelly recipe from the sources we checked, so this article does not restate her version. Check her published recipe directly before you compare it with the method below.

Pepper jelly recipes follow a few common patterns, and knowing them makes any published version easier to check.

What a standard pepper jelly includes

  • Sweet peppers, usually red and green bell peppers, for colour and body.
  • Hot peppers, such as jalapeños or other chilies, for heat. The amount sets the heat level.
  • Vinegar, for acidity.
  • Sugar, for sweetness and set.
  • A pectin source, either commercial pectin or, in pectin-free versions, a long reduction.
  • A set test, usually a cold plate or a thermometer reading around 220°F (104°C) at sea level.

Two common approaches

  1. Pectin-free reduction. Peppers, vinegar, and sugar simmer until the liquid reduces and thickens. The result is softer. See pepper jelly without pectin.
  2. With commercial pectin. The peppers are cooked with vinegar, pectin is added as the package directs, sugar is stirred in, and the mixture boils for the time the package gives before jarring.

What to check when you compare recipes

  • Pectin. Does the recipe use commercial pectin or a reduction? The method and sugar amount depend on it.
  • Sugar. Use the ratio in a tested recipe or the pectin package. Do not cut sugar in a shelf-stable recipe.
  • Processing. Processing time depends on jar size and altitude. A time from a different recipe may not fit yours. See whether to water bath or pressure can pepper jelly.
  • Storage. Is the recipe for the refrigerator or the pantry? A refrigerator recipe is not a canning recipe.
  • Heat. Check how many hot peppers it calls for, and whether it keeps the seeds.

For a full method, see pepper jelly without pectin. For the basics of pectin-free jelly, see how to make jelly without pectin.

The complete guide to jelly making

How to Make Jelly Without Pectin
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →